But, I think it was a good effort. Shafts: True Temper Dynamic Gold Tour Issue X100 (4-PW), Wedges: Glide 2.0 Stealth Wedges (50-SS, 56-SS) Callaway Mack Daddy PM Grind (60) Very minor differences in performance. Chris Wycoff is the owner of SwingFit, a custom club fitting and building studio in Hilton Head Island, SC. We use a 5 inch clamp, grip off, to do our shaft evaluation testing. Totally useless study. Shafts: True Temper Dynamic Gold Tour Issue S400. All Rights Reserved. Pingback: Dynamic Gold X100 Swing Speed Radar Launch Monitor | Golf Swing Tips. Your email address will not be published. I have three sets of clubs: TM320s withGrafalloy ProLogic. Would definitely like to see the test redone with 10-20 HCP players and AP2/G25 irons. Great article and as always a thorough presentation. Where’s the love? Currently gaming the Recoil proto 125 F5 shafts. Less than 2 degrees separated the highest launch angle from the lowest. So, make sure you have the right shaft in your irons to give you the best distance, accuracy and control so you can hit more greens in regulation! That said, I still think DGS300 is the most underestimated shaft in golf, and personally love the feel! Following the success of the KBS Carbon Fiber Hybrid shaft released in 2017, KBS has created light weight parallel iron shafts. Having seen success in graphite shafted irons in the past, I am feeling like a little kid now with the Bio Cell Black irons in stiff graphite. Someone could be an excellent ball striker with a very high swing speed but also have a really bad short game. C taper lites are the best shafts out there hands down. TM360s with TM Lite M-70 and TM R7s with Rifle 5.5 steel. The number of excluded shots was low and very consistent across the shafts, however, indicating that these were caused primarily by a swing issue and not a result of the shaft. » D'Lance GolfD'Lance Golf. Any golfer who hits down on the ball will get far more spin off of mats. This article is about how to find the right iron shaft and which iron shafts are actually suitable for you. I have tried many different shaft/clubs over the years and no what I like and works my old broken down body and decent if not slightly over the top golf swing. I’m going to have them put in my main set now and I’m very excited to see the difference. I was playing R300’s and now I game Recoil 680’s in an “X” flex. Tour Proven.â But once I get used to it they don’t really seem to make a huge difference. Shaft: Fujikura Rombax Pro 95 X, 5-wood: Nike VR_S Covert (19 degrees) Shafts: Royal Precision Project X 7.0, Wedges: Nike VR Forged (46, 52, 56, 59) $225, BGF™ Fitting System (Better Golf Faster™). This article is nice to read, and I’m sure it was limited in size. head has a little influence on the flight and spin, but in the end the right shaft will give you the best results. Our fitting recommendations include length of iron, shaft weight, shaft trajectory and spin profile, shaft flex, and swing weight. Very glad I made the switch from the c-tapers. interesting article. $149.99. Mizuno has a very nice fitting cart with a shaft analyzing device to help find the right club head and shaft for your ball striking skill level and swing. For irons, we'll focus on information regarding your 7-iron, but our recommendation will be valid for your entire set of irons. Used to play the C-tapers in S+ hard stepped once. Agreed. Drastic difference for me when I was fitted. TG verdict: If Callawayâs Apex is 2021 blade of the year, then the TaylorMade P7MB had to be blade of 2020. Please keep them coming!! Most of the avid golfers we see in our shop will spend hours combing WRX forums, reading various reviews, asking questions and trying out countless different options for their new driver shaft. The feel and how straight I hit the Loomis was what caught my attention. Thanks Golfwrx ! Iron Shaft Tests Show Big Differences. Dynamic Gold X100 Swing Speed Radar Launch Monitor | Golf Swing Tips, Great Iron Shaft Test of Top Shafts on the Market! It would be nice to see more statistics for each golfer, such as angle of attack and club head speed. In the story it says s flex. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. You must get fitted when your swing is at it’s best (end of the season) regardless of your handicap. Not enough consistency with their swings. Rather have seen x100 than s300… This is Golfwrx! That variability went away a number of years ago as graphite shaft quality control became better and better. As soon as the model launched Rory McIlroy and Charley Hull put them in their bags, and thereâs been some serious love amongst muscleback aficionados. Despite being doubters before the testing, all of our testers indicated they would strongly consider both high-end graphite options for their next set of irons. Shafts: Royal Precision Project X 6.5, Driver: Ping G400 (9 degrees @8.75) I am low single figure handicap, 55 yrs old and still have driver ss of 118. It’s been my experience that the C Taper is lower launch than most of those other shafts. I play them in winter and they are my second choice. You need to look at swing speed, feel, angle of attack, flight and spin. Quick view Compare Add to Cart. A Focus on Feel: Project X launches new Even Flow shafts, AeroTech launches TiFiber driver shafts on Tour, Spotted: Mitsubishi Chemical Tensei CK hybrid shafts, Spotted: True Temper Dynamic Gold 115 wedge shafts, Driver: TaylorMade SIM (8 degrees @8.5) Reminds me of the crappy exec courses I played that had mats (you could literally spin the ball back 15 yards). We found that you really need to find a quality fitter that allows you to try different shafts that fit your profile and see which performs the best for YOU, not your friend, pro or anyone else! Shaft: Mitsubishi Diamana D+ Limited 70 TX, 3-wood: TaylorMade SIM Titanium (15 degrees @13.5) I’ll add to the Steelfiber praise. Shipping and handling. It’s all about your own preference. Graphite shafts 15 years ago were not nearly as consistent as steel shafts. This is not true at all. A 10-20 HDCP may love the Recoils but hate the Steelfibers, or vice-versa. Graphite performs, even for very good golfers. We determine the highest CPM rating for each shaft in a test group. Two people with the same clubhead speed may need very different shafts if the way they got to impact is different. I would recommend them to anyone to try. The dispersion on the Steel Fibers is amazing and yes I can work the ball. KBSTour Graphite Iron shafts offer the feel and stability of KBSâs steel shafts in lighter weight classes. SwingFit was included on Golf Digest's list of 100 Best Clubfitters in America for 2015/16, 17/18 & 19/20 as well as Golf.com's list of 25 Elite Club Fitters in 2019 . Required fields are marked *. Why would the KBS C taper have a higher launch with both the 4i and PW when it is supposed to be a lower launching shaft compared to the KBS Tour and Tour V?? Let that shaft profile marinate for just a second. Regular? A shaft’s performance must be measured by how misses are managed. I still have a set of MP 62 with the Steel fibre shaft. SwingFit has spent the last 2 years with a Gears motion tracking system capturing thousands of swings and partnering with data scientists to research how clubs and human golf swings really interact. $22.49 ... ALL SHAFTS ARE CERTIFIED & INSPECTED TO PASS OUR QUALITY TEST Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing. For each shaft in our test, I asked four low-handicap golfers (-2 to a +2) to take five shots with a 4 iron and PW with a stiff-flex shaft using Mizuno JPX-825 Pro iron heads for each shot. A lot more to it than what was mentioned here, like an early or late release for a golfer and which shaft might perform better for that and so on. Min Woo Lee debut, Rickie’s new ball, Max Homa’s winning WITB: 2021 Genesis Invitational, ‘Big Little Lies’ star Kathryn Newton showcases stunning golf swing at Pebble Beach, Daniel Berger’s winning WITB: 2021 AT&T Pro-Am, Interesting photos from the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am (plus links to all galleries). Note*: In this study, we attempted to correlate shaft performance differences with differences in the golfers’ swings. View All Clubs Just like when everyone use to play steel in woods now you don’t see a one on Tour! The (mostly) unpaid endorsement of the shafts by the PGA Tourâs best players, of course, validates and amplifyâs KBS Shaftsâ key message, which is, âPlayer Driven. I hope they’re not too light, but I guess i could sell them on ebay fast as pullouts. Also what shafts were you playing before the switch. Am very pleased with them. Can Golf Iron Shafts Be Too Flexible?. So that shaft that was just perfect during my fitting did in fact perform better because I’m more aware of my transition tempo, for example, and strike the ball better. Expensive but well worth it imo. It’s not a pretty picture. I just think that more information would paint the whole picture. GST or 4 payments of $ 21.25 with Afterpay I see now positive improvement in changing to one of the newer models. It’s no wonder the DGS300, Project X 6.0, KBS Tour and KBS C Tapers all were about the same for me in terms of performance. To me, it seems odd. For the price you can’t really beat good ole S300’s. We use a 204 gram weight for wood shafts and a 260 gram weight for hybrid and iron shaft testing. No surprise that strong golfers performed well with S300s. Driver and Fairway Wood Fitting – Reg. thanks. Am I missing something? Just because someone has the same S.S. does not mean he will love the same shafts as you. I went to Steel Fiber 95s a month or so ago in a set of BS DPC because I was developing tendonitis in both elbows. i would consider this if i was for example, trying to control off-line deviation, or backspin, as these will help with distance to the pin. At last, the term EI profile, is part of the discussion shaft companies are having with golfers. Very consistent. Quick view Compare Add to Cart. Others Iâve tinkered with are Oban (at least four of their line-up), UST (Elements is great), Paderson (wildly underrated and deserving of anyoneâs look even in iron shafts), and other Aldila shafts. During the fitting, it was night and day, in feel, when switching between stock shafts and the ProjectX shafts (fitted with a 7 iron). Living in Hilton Head, I got a front row seat for Matt Kuchar’s win with a set of SteelFibers. To that end, the shafts in this test feature different weights, different materials, and different bend profiles. Shaft designers have many ways to change the performance and feel of a golf shaft â the materials used and the way they are cut and oriented all impact specs such as torque, frequency and weight. Even with older model irons, the graphite shafts available were whippier than steel of the same flex, although those were stock graphite shafts of the OEM’s and not premium (and expensive) aftermarket graphite shafts. Hard to compare all these shafts side by side unless they all frequency out the same. If these graphite shafts were cheaper, I’d have tried more. Other than weight, I don’t see much difference in either of them insofar as distance and accuracy is concerned. Some (if not all) of them probably play X100s. In this edition of WITB Time Machine, we take. a look at Rory McIlroy’s gear from the 2014 Ryder Cup when he was still a Nike staffer. That doesn’t mean the results aren’t valid. Graphite vs steel shafts at a glance In summary Nippon iron shafts reader test at Tour X. by James Savage | March 15, 2017 | Equipment. We fit a LOT of different golfers every year and the shafts we put into their irons (and wedges) is determined by our BGF Fitting System, TrueFitClubs Fitting Wizard and player testing during the fitting. Shimada K'S-3001 Stiff Iron Set Shaft Set 6Pc .355 677974. Here are the shafts we used in our testing: We tracked the average ball speed, launch angle, backspin, carry distance, carry deviation, decent angle and distance offline. All rights reserved. I have been playing the SteelFiber i95’s for a few months now. People: just get fitted at the proper time and you’ll know which shafts work best FOR YOU. Thanks! Dispersion is no problem and I find the slightly higher launch angle a great help. Also, some golf club companies cheat on their shaft flex markings. For me, the KBS not only felt weaker, but played weaker as well. We recently conducted a series of tests for a major shaft company to understand the differences in launch angle, spin, carry distance and total distance among several shafts. Doing a shaft test with golfers all between +2 and 2 handicaps isn’t really very relevant to me. But at this point, there’s no rush! I think PX 5.5 and C-Taper R+ flexes (and maybe R+ in KBS Tour) are more comparable to S300 and Modus120 stiff. In this edition of WITB Time Machine, we take. I’m a 10 and love the Recoils, X100’s and the modus120’s. So knowing how things went based on past experience, this will be an exciting time for me! The list is sorted by MPF, with the most flexible shafts at the top of the list and progressing to the extra stiff shaft options. May I ask your handicap and approximate swing speed? You might be surprised how your perception of feel might be changed by performance. What this testing really proves to me, and hopefully for you, is that everyone can really benefit from taking a fresh look at what they’re playing and do a thorough fitting. I hooked the crap out of the PX 6.5 shafts I had very briefly and broke my hand. Tote – Our fitting recommendations include length of iron, shaft weight, shaft trajectory and spin profile, shaft flex, and swing weight. I found this article interesting. The big difference was that each shaft had quite different characteristics so the effect on distance was significant. What’s your explanation for the C Taper having the highest launch of all the shafts? Not only that, DeChambeauâs current iron shafts are more than 10 grams lighter (120 grams) than X7. The flexibility of the shafts you should be playing is linked to your swing speed. For some reason, these same golfers simply don’t pay attention to the shafts that go into their irons, even though there are typically at least eight of them in their bag versus just one driver. I figure that now with the Black Bio Cell irons I will see more improvement immediately and can work from there into the steel shafted irons. Agree. For you they are. Michael, your handicap means nothing in terms of fitting you for the right iron shaft. The order we hit the shafts was random and the shots were broken into three different hitting sessions to ensure that fatigue didn’t skew any numbers. Learn how your comment data is processed. The Steelfiber i95s are the easiest on my body by far. Go get fit and stop looking at these tests because it will tell you nothing about how you swing(tempo, load, unload etc). Becasue you TOTALLY get to do that on the course. Shafts don’t care what your handicap is. I fitted for the Ping i20 (wound up purchasing the i25’s, due to availability at the time) with ProjectX 5.5 shafts. I am switching to SteelFiber soon and am still trying to determine In my view people change clubs to often as every small change takes time to adjust to. Spin was quite a different story with the lowest spin rate at 4796 and the highest at 6264. The Aldila Tour Green is a perfect hybrid shaft for me cuz I want those to feel more like my iron shafts (DG TI) than my woods. Stiff? We tested 10 shafts, both graphite and steel, of varying weights. Great to see some group testing like this!! The problem is usually that players do not approach the matter objectively. Can’t believe they could get Aldila RIP Tour to be in this iron shaft test. I was fitted with S-300, but opted for X-100 for the feel and tighter shot dispersion. For example, our testers expressed concern about the dispersion with the Nippon N.S. It isn’t that simple, the shaft will give the player the right launch and spin. The original purpose of this testing was to provide a data-driven guide to help better players select what shafts to put in irons. My Driver is a D3 910 Titleist with custom vir Accra shaft. I can only imagine the confidence and extra length that comes with such a switch will work very well in my favor! I also like how the carry deviation is the the same or greater in the PW vs the 4 iron. Few things in golf are so universally true. I really like the pings because they have minimum offset for a game improving iron, the new forged look like they have too much offset. Keep it Simple. We'll also recommend hybrid and fairway wood shafts that fit your input. Kudos to moderngolf. Posted by admin in From the Lab, Manufacturer News, Shaft Tests and Reviews, Site News, Tour News. Shaft doesn’t care if you are scratch or a 30 handicap. Posted by admin in From the Lab, Manufacturer News, Shaft Tests and Reviews, Site News, Tour News. The feel feedback indicated the Recoils could be felt loading and unloading during the swing more than the SteelFibers and provided a “pop” at impact. For me, I’ve always liked PX’s. I switched to graphite from steel in the early to mid-90s and noticed significant improvement and a greater confidence in my game. Shaft: Mitsubishi Diamana S+ 72 X, 3-wood: Nike VRS Covert 2.0 (15 degrees) So to help, we did data-driven, head-to-head comparison of several of the top iron shafts for better players. Doesn’t matter what the manufacturer says, it’s about the individual’s swing. You won’t find that “cheating” with good quality after-market shafts like the Aerotechs or Recoils. How a shaft feels should not be the first criteria used when selecting a shaft. Prior to joining the golf world, Chris was a management consultant for over 7 years and brings a great deal of the data driven processes from that world into golf. $149.99 + $14.95 shipping. The overall averages for all of the testers combined may have shown very little variance, but the example involving the performance differences for golfer A and B with the Recoil shows that every golfer will see a noticeable difference from shaft to shaft. Instead, my hypothesis was that certain shafts would distinguish themselves in one or two areas and potentially fall behind in others. Extra Stiff? Using the correct flex probably would have made these shafts perform even closer in comparison. Yet the very shafts that are too flexible for you might be too stiff for another player. I can see a day when Steel will be phased out and graphite will be the norm in irons. What works for you may not work the best for a lot of other people. Never tried any of the others. Stock shaft: KBS Tour. When picking a shaft, what matters is swing speed, feel, angle of attack, launch angle and spin, NOT HANDICAP. There was no distance difference. Given it’s not available anymore I was hoping for some more “mainstream” testers when I saw the headline. Shaft: Fujikura Ventus Red 9 X, Irons: Ping Blueprint (4-PW) We fit a LOT of different golfers every year and the shafts we put into their irons (and wedges) is determined by our BGF Fitting System, TrueFitClubs Fitting Wizard and player testing during the fitting. Hit a demo #6 iron and my launch angle and spin were the same as DGS300 but increased ball speed by 3 mph. keep it simple!! We were unable to do the correlation as a result of our limited sample size. The SteelFibers felt stable like steel throughout. ProMade Irons provides a stiff ⦠Take the Aerotech SteelFiber performance for Golfers A & B from the table below. Sat 31 Xcaliber RT Iron Shafts. A versatile iron that can fit anyone from pros to better weekend warriors, the 919 Forged fits snugly between the Tour and Hot Metal models. If the lighter shaft weight is offset be adding weight to the heads, the shafts will flex a little more, but that is due to the heavier heads weights, not whippier shafts. Would have loved to see how C Taper Lite, and Aerotech 95 would have stacked up even though they are lighter. The 2021 Performance Shaft Guide is now available. As with much in golf, my research findings didn’t turn out quite that simple. Enjoy and play well all good people. The test head was a Mizuno MP-58 6 iron. All shafts were built to within a half a flex of the specs for both golfers testing the shafts. Add the expense of graphite, and regular golfers won’t go to them. Posted by Dan Sueltz in Site News Never would’ve thought my SS would tell me to get x stiff iron shafts but they have made a heck of a difference in my iron game. Graphite shafts are much lighter and more expensive in comparison to steel shafts, and weigh between 50 and 85 grams. © 2012 D'Lance Golf. I keep ending up back with my Mizuno JPX with the TT Dynalyte XP S300. I absolutely hate PX shafts. Too many golfers use the same iron shafts they’ve been gaming since the last time they were fit (usually at a demo day, a couple of sets ago) or use whatever might come as stock. Spin is the one variable that makes no sense when looking at the shaft profiles and the above results. F5 is x flex. High launch and spin with consistently strong results. So can the shafts of hybrids, fairway metals and drivers. As a senior, we need more info for us average Joe’s who don’t carry a 2-5 handicap and don’t have a 100mph swing speed. This is really good stuff! Martin – I understand that the scratch testers might not have the most relevance to you, but I think the results still do. I’ve been plagued by joint and bone issues since I started playing just 2 years ago. lots of negative nelle’s here that are never satisfied with anything produced. I tried the C Tapes and for me they where a disaster. How We Determine Best Performing Shafts. As a result, the lightweight shafts on graphite irons can help to create a greater swing speed for more power. Our findings indicate that everyone should take a fresh look at what shafts should go into their next set of irons. They could be an 18 handicap as a result. Thanks, shows me that feel really is the deciding factor if I like my ball flight. There is no simple answer to the question of what is the best shaft, regardless of handicap. Take a minute to check out all the new featured shafts including Diamana⢠TB, TENSEI⢠Pro White 1K, and MMT⢠Iron Shafts. It took a while to adjust mentally but now I am loving it. is slightly different. That is because even very good golfers’ swings vary a lot from one golfer to another. We used a Foresight GC2 launch monitor to track all the results. Fujikuraâs graphite iron shafts have been designed to provide all golfers â from Tour players to aspirational golfers â performance and feel that isometric steel iron shafts simply canât create. That is why custom fitting is so important. » D'Lance GolfD'Lance Golf. NEW KBS TOUR BLACK NICKEL 110G REGULAR IRON SHAFT SET 4 ⦠Ultimately the shaft that FEELS the best to you will perform the best as you will deliver it the best, performance comes from the Head, feel comes from the shaft, control comes from the flex….
Army Regulation On Pt While Clearing,
What Is Zina In Islam,
Lifting An Atv,
Violet Elaine Tubb,
1959 Chevy Station Wagon,